VFD tripping breakers or dimming lights?

Drive-related harmonics, EMC issues, and motor starting inrush can cause equipment downtime, nuisance trips, and flicker. We diagnose VFD harmonic sources, recommend filters, and advise on soft starter vs VFD choices.

Common Symptoms

Flicker, overheating transformers, and EMC issues that stem from drives.

What is one of the most visible signs of harmonic distortion affecting lighting in a facility with VFDs?

Flickering or dimming lights are a frequent symptom, occurring when harmonic currents from VFDs cause voltage fluctuations or instability in the power supply. This happens because harmonics distort the voltage waveform, leading to rapid changes in voltage levels that sensitive lighting systems can't handle smoothly.

Why might circuit breakers trip unexpectedly in systems using VFDs?

Harmonic currents generated by VFDs can overload circuit breakers, causing them to trip even without an apparent short circuit or overload. These extra currents add to the heating in breakers, triggering thermal or electronic trips prematurely, and can lead to nuisance tripping or premature wear.

How do harmonics from VFDs contribute to blown fuses or increased current draw?

High harmonic distortion increases the overall current in the system, which can blow fuses or cause excessive current draw. VFDs introduce non-sinusoidal currents that stress fuses beyond their rated capacity, leading to frequent replacements and potential system downtime.

What other equipment-related symptoms might indicate harmonic issues caused by VFDs?

Overheating of motors, transformers, or cables is common, as harmonics cause additional losses and eddy currents that generate excess heat. This can result in reduced equipment lifespan, vibrations in motors, or audible noise from transformers.

Can harmonic distortion from VFDs affect sensitive electronic devices or overall system operation?

Yes, it can lead to erratic operation or failure of sensitive equipment, such as computers or control systems, due to distorted voltage waveforms. This might cause unexpected downtime, malfunctioning machinery, or inaccurate sensor readings.

How can I confirm if these symptoms are due to harmonics from VFDs?

Use a power quality analyzer to measure THDi and THDv levels at the point of common coupling or near the VFDs. If harmonics exceed standards like IEEE 519 (e.g., THDv above 5%), they are likely the culprit. Monitoring during peak VFD operation can help correlate symptoms with harmonic spikes.

Soft Starter vs VFD

Differences Between Soft Starters and Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs)

Soft starters and Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) are motor control devices designed to manage electric motor startups, but they differ in operation and purpose. A soft starter gradually ramps up the voltage to the motor during startup (and sometimes shutdown), reducing inrush current and mechanical stress. It uses thyristors or SCRs to control voltage, typically bypassing to a direct connection once the motor reaches full speed, offering no ongoing speed control. In contrast, a VFD converts fixed-frequency AC power to DC and then to variable-frequency AC, enabling precise control over motor speed, torque, and acceleration throughout operation. VFDs provide dynamic adjustments by varying frequency and voltage, ideal for applications requiring variable performance.

The primary differences lie in functionality and complexity. Soft starters, such as those from ABB, WEG, LS Electric, and Danfoss offered by Gross Automation, focus on smooth startups to protect equipment, making them simpler and suited for fixed-speed applications. VFDs, including Danfoss (proudly featured by Gross Automation), ABB, WEG, and LS Electric models, provide full operational control, optimizing energy use for variable loads like pumps or fans.

Why Choose One Over the Other?

The choice between a soft starter and a VFD depends on your application’s needs, including whether variable speed is required, energy efficiency goals, space constraints, and budget. Choose a soft starter from ABB, WEG, LS Electric, or Danfoss if your motor operates at a constant speed after startup (e.g., compressors, elevators, or fixed conveyors). These devices reduce inrush current (often 6-8 times normal), mechanical wear, and peak demand charges, ideal for high-inertia loads where simplicity is key. Opt for a VFD, such as Danfoss, ABB, WEG, or LS Electric models from Gross Automation, if you need ongoing speed control for varying loads (e.g., fans, pumps, or mixers). VFDs can save up to 50% energy by adjusting speed to match demand, potentially reducing annual costs significantly for large motors. For example, a VFD is better for applications requiring precise torque control at low speeds, like escalators, while a soft starter suffices for smooth starts in fixed-speed systems.

KVAR (Reactive Power) Advantages

KVAR (kilovolt-amperes reactive) measures reactive power, which burdens the system without performing useful work. Soft starters from ABB, WEG, LS Electric, and Danfoss have minimal impact on KVAR, often maintaining a near-unity power factor (PF) after bypassing, which can reduce reactive power penalties from utilities. They may require external capacitors for PF correction in some setups (e.g., adding 25 KVAR for certain motors). VFDs, like those from Danfoss, ABB, WEG, or LS Electric, can improve PF in variable-load applications by optimizing motor operation, potentially lowering KVAR and reducing utility costs. However, VFDs may introduce harmonics that could increase reactive power needs unless mitigated with filters. For variable loads, VFDs’ energy savings often outweigh KVAR drawbacks, but soft starters are preferable for PF stability in fixed-speed applications.

Are Some Soft Starters Better Than Others? Are Some VFDs Better Than Others?

Among the brands carried by Gross Automation, ABB, WEG, LS Electric, and Danfoss soft starters each offer reliable performance tailored to different needs. ABB soft starters are known for robust construction and integration with automation systems, WEG models excel in compact design and energy efficiency, LS Electric provides cost-effective solutions with solid performance, and Danfoss offers advanced features like user-friendly interfaces and harmonic mitigation. Higher-end models from these brands include diagnostics, built-in bypass contactors, and harmonic reduction capabilities, enhancing reliability compared to basic models.

For VFDs, Gross Automation proudly features Danfoss for its industry-leading efficiency and advanced features like integrated harmonic mitigation and IoT connectivity. ABB, WEG, and LS Electric VFDs also offer strong performance, with ABB excelling in heavy-duty applications, WEG in robust and versatile designs, and LS Electric in budget-friendly options with dependable operation. Premium VFDs from these brands often include built-in filters, better energy optimization, and user-friendly interfaces, making them ideal for complex systems, while entry-level models suit simpler applications.

Price Difference

VFDs are typically 2-3 times more expensive than soft starters due to their advanced functionality. For a 50HP motor in 2025, an ABB, WEG, LS Electric, or Danfoss soft starter might cost $350–$3,000, while a Danfoss, ABB, WEG, or LS Electric VFD could range from $1,000–$6,000 or more, depending on features like enclosures or harmonic mitigation. The higher cost of VFDs can be offset by energy savings in variable-speed applications.

Robustness and Service Requirements

Soft starters from ABB, WEG, LS Electric, and Danfoss are generally more robust due to their simpler design, with fewer components prone to failure, making them reliable in harsh industrial environments. They generate less heat, especially with bypass contactors, and require minimal maintenance, typically just periodic inspections.

VFDs from Danfoss, ABB, WEG, and LS Electric are robust but more complex, with active electronics (e.g., IGBTs) that generate more heat and may require additional cooling or filters. They need more frequent maintenance, such as fan replacements, firmware updates, and harmonic checks, particularly in dusty or variable-load settings.

Do You Need a Starter Panel?

Whether a starter panel is needed depends on the installation. Gross Automation offers complete starter panels from Streamline Automation Technologies, which provide robust enclosures for soft starters and VFDs, ensuring protection, proper wiring, and control integration. Soft starters from ABB, WEG, LS Electric, or Danfoss often benefit from such panels, though their compact size may allow direct panel mounting in some cases. VFDs, including Danfoss, ABB, WEG, or LS Electric models, typically require a dedicated panel or cabinet due to their larger size, heat dissipation needs, and additional components like filters. Streamline Automation Technologies’ panels ensure safety and compliance (e.g., NEMA ratings) for both, though small, integrated units may not always need one.

Standards

IEC 61800-3: Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) for Power Drive Systems

This international standard sets limits on the "noise" (electromagnetic interference and harmonics) that VFDs and similar drive systems can produce. It categorizes systems into groups (C1 for homes, C2 for light industry, C3 for heavy industry, C4 for very high power) based on where they're used. For example, in a home or office (C1), noise must be very low to avoid messing with radios or computers; in a factory (C3), higher levels are okay but still limited to prevent equipment damage.

What it says simply: Think of it as rules for keeping electrical signals clean—like not letting your device's "static" buzz interfere with the TV next door. It limits harmonic distortion (wavy power signals that waste energy or overheat wires) and requires testing for emissions.

Applies to: Mainly VFDs, but soft starters may reference it for EMC if integrated into drive systems.

IEEE 519: Recommended Practices and Requirements for Harmonic Control in Electric Power Systems

This U.S.-based guideline (often used worldwide) focuses on limiting harmonics in the overall power system, not just one device. Harmonics are like ripples in a pond that can build up and cause problems like overheating transformers or flickering lights. It sets limits on total harmonic distortion (THD) for voltage (usually under 5-8%) and current (based on system size, e.g., 5-20% TDD—total demand distortion). Measurements are taken at the "point of common coupling" (where your system connects to the utility's grid).

What it says simply: It's like a neighborhood rule: Your devices (VFDs or soft starters) can't create too many ripples that affect everyone else's power. For VFDs, which create more harmonics, you might need filters to comply; soft starters produce fewer, so they're often fine without extras. Utilities might enforce this to avoid fines or service issues.

Applies to: Both VFDs and soft starters, but more critical for VFDs due to higher harmonic generation.

IEC 60947-4-2: Low-Voltage Switchgear and Controlgear—AC Semiconductor Motor Controllers and Starters

This is the main international standard for soft starters (and similar controllers). It covers performance, safety, and testing, including how they handle starting/stopping motors without excessive current surges. It includes requirements for overload protection, short-circuit withstand, and EMC.

What it says simply: It's a rulebook for soft starters to start motors gently without causing big power spikes that could trip breakers or damage parts. It ensures the device is tough enough for real-world use, like in factories, and tests for safety features like thermal protection.

Applies to: Primarily soft starters; VFDs fall under IEC 61800 series instead.

UL Standards (e.g., UL 508C, UL 61800-5-1, UL 60947-4-1)

Underwriters Laboratories (UL) provides U.S. safety certifications. UL 508C is for power conversion equipment like VFDs, ensuring they won't overheat or fail dangerously. UL 61800-5-1 aligns with IEC for drive safety, and UL 60947-4-1 is the U.S. version of IEC 60947-4-1 for soft starters and controllers.

What it says simply: UL tests devices to make sure they're safe—like checking a toy for sharp edges. It looks at fire risks, electrical shocks, and durability under stress. Products get a UL label if they pass, which is often required for insurance or building codes.

Applies to: Both; UL 508C/UL 61800-5-1 for VFDs, UL 60947-4-1 for soft starters.

CE Marking (EU Directives: EMC 2014/30/EU, Low Voltage 2014/35/EU)

CE isn't a single standard but a mark showing compliance with EU rules. It often requires meeting EN 61800-3 (European version of IEC 61800-3) for EMC in drives, and EN 61800-5-1 or EN 60947-4-2 for safety.

What it says simply: It's like a passport for selling in Europe: The device must be safe, not cause interference, and meet environmental rules. For VFDs/soft starters, this means low noise and reliable operation to avoid harming people or other gear.

Applies to: Both, mandatory for EU markets.

Other Standards to Consider

NFPA 70 (National Electrical Code): U.S. code for safe installation, including wiring and labeling for VFDs/soft starters. Simply: Rules for hooking things up without causing fires or shocks.

NEMA ICS Standards: For industrial controls, covering enclosures and ratings. Simply: Ensures devices are built tough for factory environments.

IEC/EN 61800-5-1: Safety for drives, including emergency stops. Simply: Makes sure the device stops safely if something goes wrong.

Related pages

Not sure if we cover your area? See our complete service-area list.