Stop paying PF penalties—size kVAR right
Power factor correction, capacitor bank sizing, and power factor audits to reduce utility power factor penalties and improve facility energy efficiency. We offer PF correction services, detuned capacitor solutions, and industrial electrical repair for manufacturing and commercial sites.
PF Basics
What is Power Factor?
Imagine electricity flowing to your home or business like a river of water you pay for. Not all of that "water" does useful work—like powering lights or running machines. Some of it just sloshes around without helping. Power factor (PF) is a simple measure of how efficiently you're using the electricity you get from the utility company. It's a number between 0 and 1 (or 0% to 100%), where 1 (or 100%) means you're using every bit of power effectively, with no waste. A low power factor, like 0.7 (70%), means about 30% of the electricity is "wasted" in a way that doesn't do real work, even though you're still paying for it.
Power factor gets low when devices like motors, transformers, or fluorescent lights need extra "reactive" energy to create magnetic fields that help them run. This reactive part doesn't turn into heat, motion, or light—it's like the foam in a beer glass: necessary but not the actual drink. Utilities care about power factor because low PF forces them to generate and deliver more total power than what's actually needed, straining their equipment like wires and transformers.
Power factor gets low when devices like motors, transformers, or fluorescent lights need extra "reactive" energy to create magnetic fields that help them run. This reactive part doesn't turn into heat, motion, or light—it's like the foam in a beer glass: necessary but not the actual drink. Utilities care about power factor because low PF forces them to generate and deliver more total power than what's actually needed, straining their equipment like wires and transformers.
What is KVAR?
KVAR stands for kilovolt-amperes reactive—it's the unit that measures that "reactive" or wasted part of electricity I mentioned. Think of it as the foam in the beer analogy: It's the portion of power that bounces back and forth between your equipment and the utility without being consumed as useful energy. KVAR is measured in thousands (kilo), just like kilowatts (kW) for real power or kilovolt-amperes (kVA) for total power.
High KVAR happens with inductive loads (things that use coils or magnets, like motors or air conditioners). It doesn't show up on your energy meter as consumed power, but it still costs the utility to supply it. That's why fixing high KVAR (by adding devices like capacitors) can improve your power factor and lower bills.
High KVAR happens with inductive loads (things that use coils or magnets, like motors or air conditioners). It doesn't show up on your energy meter as consumed power, but it still costs the utility to supply it. That's why fixing high KVAR (by adding devices like capacitors) can improve your power factor and lower bills.
The Relationship Between kW, kVA, and kVAR
To understand how these fit together, picture a right-angled triangle (called the power triangle):
The math is straightforward: kVA is the combination of kW and kVAR. Specifically, kVA² = kW² + kVAR² (like the Pythagorean theorem for the triangle). Power factor is kW divided by kVA—if kVAR is high, PF drops because more of the total power is reactive.
Example: If a machine uses 80 kW of real power but needs 60 kVAR of reactive power, the total apparent power is √(80² + 60²) = 100 kVA. The power factor is 80/100 = 0.8 (80%). Lowering kVAR (say, to 0) would make PF = 1, and kVA = 80, meaning the utility supplies less total power for the same work.
- kW (Real Power): This is the useful power that does actual work, like running a motor or lighting a bulb. It's what your energy meter mainly tracks, and it's billed as kilowatt-hours (kWh).
- kVA (Apparent Power): This is the total power supplied by the utility—the full "glass" in the beer analogy, including both beer and foam. It's what the utility has to provide to meet your demand.
- kVAR (Reactive Power): The "foam"—the extra power needed but not used for work.
The math is straightforward: kVA is the combination of kW and kVAR. Specifically, kVA² = kW² + kVAR² (like the Pythagorean theorem for the triangle). Power factor is kW divided by kVA—if kVAR is high, PF drops because more of the total power is reactive.
Example: If a machine uses 80 kW of real power but needs 60 kVAR of reactive power, the total apparent power is √(80² + 60²) = 100 kVA. The power factor is 80/100 = 0.8 (80%). Lowering kVAR (say, to 0) would make PF = 1, and kVA = 80, meaning the utility supplies less total power for the same work.
Power Terms Table
Term | What It Measures | Analogy | Why It Matters |
---|---|---|---|
kW | Useful work done (e.g., motion, heat) | The beer you drink | What you're billed for in energy use. |
kVA | Total power supplied | The full glass (beer + foam) | Utility's total delivery burden. |
kVAR | Reactive/wasted component | The foam | Increases costs if too high; lowers PF. |
How Do Utilities Apply Power Factor Penalties?
Utilities want you to keep a high power factor (usually above 0.9 or 95%) because low PF means they have to oversized their equipment to handle the extra reactive power, leading to higher costs for them. If your PF is too low, they add a penalty to your bill to encourage you to fix it—think of it as a fine for inefficiency.
Here's how it typically works, simply:
Penalties vary by utility and location—some in the U.S. (like in California or Texas) might waive them for small users, but industrial sites can face thousands in extra costs yearly. The good news? Improving PF with capacitors or better equipment often pays for itself quickly through savings. Check your utility's tariff (rate schedule) for specifics, as rules differ (e.g., some use "lagging PF" for inductive loads).
Here's how it typically works, simply:
- Monitoring: The utility measures your power factor over a billing period (e.g., monthly) using meters that track kW, kVA, and sometimes kVAR directly.
- Threshold: Most utilities penalize if PF falls below a set level, like 0.9. For example, if yours is 0.85, you're in penalty territory.
- Penalty Calculation: Common methods include:
- kVAR Charge: A direct fee per kVAR used (e.g., $0.50–$2 per kVAR per month). If you have 100 kVAR excess, that's $50–$200 extra.
- kVA Demand Adjustment: They bill based on apparent power (kVA) instead of real power (kW), or multiply your demand charge by a factor (e.g., if PF is 0.8, charge 1.25 times the normal rate).
- Percentage Surcharge: Add 1–5% to your total bill for every 0.01 below the threshold.
Penalties vary by utility and location—some in the U.S. (like in California or Texas) might waive them for small users, but industrial sites can face thousands in extra costs yearly. The good news? Improving PF with capacitors or better equipment often pays for itself quickly through savings. Check your utility's tariff (rate schedule) for specifics, as rules differ (e.g., some use "lagging PF" for inductive loads).
Related pages
See our full service area list to confirm coverage in your city.
Detuned vs Non-Detuned
What Are Detuned and Non-Detuned Systems?
Capacitor banks are often used to improve power factor by supplying reactive power (kVAR) locally, reducing the burden on the utility and avoiding PF penalties. However, in systems with VFDs or soft starters, harmonics (unwanted electrical “noise” or ripples in the power waveform) can complicate things. Detuned and non-detuned refer to how these capacitor systems are designed to handle harmonics.
Non-Detuned Capacitor Banks
- What it means: Standard capacitor banks that add reactive power to improve PF without special protection against harmonics. Assumes the power system is “clean” (low harmonics).
- How it works: Capacitors are connected directly to offset the reactive power (kVAR) needed by motors or inductive loads, boosting PF closer to 1. Sized to match the kVAR needed.
- Why it’s used: Simpler, cheaper, and work well in systems with minimal harmonics (mostly linear loads). Common in older or less complex setups.
- Risks in VFD systems: VFDs generate harmonics, which can resonate with non-detuned capacitors, amplifying harmonics and causing voltage spikes, overheating, or capacitor failure. Can lead to tripped breakers or dimmed lights.
Detuned Capacitor Banks
- What it means: Capacitor banks paired with a reactor tuned to prevent resonance with harmonics. “Detuned” means the system avoids amplifying common harmonic frequencies.
- How it works: Reactor and capacitor form a filter that shifts the system’s resonant frequency away from harmonic frequencies. Still corrects PF and reduces harmonic distortion.
- Why it’s used: Ideal for environments with VFDs, soft starters, or other non-linear loads. Prevents resonance, reduces THDi and THDv, and protects equipment.
- Benefits: Safer and more reliable in modern systems with high harmonic loads, extends equipment life, and ensures compliance with standards like IEEE 519.
Key Differences in Simple Terms
Imagine your power system as a pool of water. Non-detuned capacitors are like adding a bucket of water to keep the pool full (improving PF) but can make waves (harmonics) bigger if you’re not careful. Detuned capacitors are like adding the same bucket with a filter that calms the waves, keeping the pool steady even with VFDs stirring things up.
Feature Comparison Table
Feature | Non-Detuned | Detuned |
---|---|---|
Purpose | Adds kVAR to fix PF | Adds kVAR and prevents harmonic issues |
Components | Just capacitors | Capacitors + reactor (filter) |
Best for | Low-harmonic systems (e.g., resistive loads) | High-harmonic systems (e.g., VFDs, soft starters) |
Cost | Cheaper (e.g., $2,000 for 50 kVAR) | More expensive (e.g., $3,000–$5,000 for 50 kVAR) |
Risks | Resonance can amplify harmonics, causing damage | Avoids resonance, safer for equipment |
Why It Matters
- Non-detuned capacitors can worsen VFD-related problems by amplifying harmonics, leading to voltage distortion (THDv) and current distortion (THDi).
- Detuned systems improve PF while safely handling harmonics, prevent resonance, and help meet IEEE 519 standards.
- Soft starters produce fewer harmonics, so non-detuned capacitors might suffice, but detuned systems are safer if any VFDs are present.
Practical Considerations
- When to use non-detuned: Low harmonics, mostly linear loads. Cost-effective for PF correction.
- When to use detuned: Systems with VFDs—strongly recommended. Prevents harmonic-related issues, especially in industrial settings.
- How to decide: Use a power quality analyzer to measure THDi and THDv. If THDv > 5% or THDi is high (>10%), detuned systems are necessary.
- Installation with Gross Automation products: Detuned capacitor banks paired with Streamline Automation Technologies’ starter panels ensure compliance and reliability. Danfoss VFDs often include built-in harmonic mitigation, which pairs well with detuned banks.
Risk of Leading PF
What is a Leading Power Factor?
Power factor measures how efficiently electricity is used, ranging from 0 to 1 (or 0% to 100%). A PF of 1 is ideal, meaning all power is used for real work (like running motors). Normally, motors and VFDs cause a lagging PF (below 1) because they need extra reactive power (kVAR) to operate, which capacitor banks supply to “fix” the PF. A leading PF occurs when you add too many capacitors, supplying more kVAR than needed. This flips the system, making it act like it’s sending reactive power back to the utility, resulting in a PF still less than 1 but in the opposite direction (e.g., 0.95 leading instead of lagging).
Think of it like pouring too much sugar into your coffee—it’s not just right anymore; it’s overly sweet and might taste bad. In electrical terms, this excess reactive power can cause problems for your equipment and the power grid.
Think of it like pouring too much sugar into your coffee—it’s not just right anymore; it’s overly sweet and might taste bad. In electrical terms, this excess reactive power can cause problems for your equipment and the power grid.
What Are the Risks of a Leading Power Factor?
- Voltage Instability: Too much reactive power can increase system voltage (overvoltage), stressing equipment insulation and risking failures or reduced lifespan in motors, transformers, or VFDs.
- Tripping Breakers or Equipment Shutdowns: Overvoltage can trigger protective devices like circuit breakers or VFDs to trip, causing unexpected downtime.
- Dimming or Flickering Lights: Excessive reactive power can cause voltage fluctuations, leading to light dimming or flickering, especially in systems with sensitive lighting or VFD-driven loads.
- Utility Penalties: Some utilities penalize leading PF as well as lagging PF, because it strains their grid by pushing reactive power back.
- Harmonic Amplification: In systems with VFDs, a leading PF can worsen harmonic issues if non-detuned capacitors are used, amplifying THDi or THDv.
How Does This Happen?
- Overcorrecting with Capacitors: Adding more kVAR than needed can push PF into leading territory.
- Light Load Conditions: VFDs or soft starters on motors running at low load need less kVAR, but fixed capacitors keep supplying the same amount, causing a leading PF.
- VFDs with Built-in Correction: Some VFDs have built-in power factor correction, which, if paired with external capacitors, can tip the system into leading PF.
How to Avoid or Fix Leading PF
- Size Capacitors Correctly: Use a power quality analyzer to measure kVAR needs and install capacitors that match the system’s reactive power demand.
- Use Automatic Capacitor Banks: These switch capacitors on/off based on real-time PF, preventing overcorrection.
- Choose Detuned Capacitors: In VFD-heavy systems, detuned banks prevent harmonic resonance and are less likely to cause leading PF issues.
- Monitor PF Regularly: Check PF with a meter, especially during low-load periods, to ensure it stays between 0.95 lagging and 0.95 leading.
- Consult Utility or Engineer: Review tariffs and system design to ensure compliance with standards like IEEE 519.
Practical Example
Suppose your facility uses Danfoss, ABB, WEG, or LS Electric VFDs from Gross Automation, and you’ve added a non-detuned 50 kVAR capacitor bank to correct a lagging PF of 0.8. If the motors run at low load (needing only 20 kVAR), the excess 30 kVAR could push PF to 0.97 leading, raising voltages and risking breaker trips or light flickering. Switching to a detuned, automatic capacitor bank could dynamically adjust kVAR, keeping PF near 1 and minimizing harmonic-related issues.
Summary Table
Aspect | Leading PF Issue | Impact | How to Mitigate |
---|---|---|---|
Cause | Too many capacitors or low-load VFDs | Overvoltage, harmonic issues | Size capacitors correctly, use automatic banks |
Equipment Risk | Breaker trips, equipment failure | Downtime, repair costs | Use detuned capacitors, monitor PF |
Utility Impact | Possible penalties | Higher bills | Check utility tariff, aim for 0.95–1 PF |
VFD Context | Worse with non-detuned capacitors | Tripping, light dimming | Pair with detuned systems, Gross Automation solutions |